Menu of Olive's Pitaria in Cape Girardeau, Missouri, USA

Menu Overview

Olive's Pitaria, nestled at 340 S Lorimier St in Cape Girardeau, Missouri, offers a Mediterranean dining experience that feels both authentic and inviting. This restaurant captures the essence of Mediterranean cuisine with a carefully curated menu that balances robust flavors and fresh ingredients, creating dishes that are vibrant yet comforting.

The standout starters are nothing short of spectacular. The Feta Fries are a must-try—string fries generously topped with gyro meat, crumbled feta, creamy tzatziki, chopped onions, and melted cheese. Every bite delivers layers of flavor that feel indulgent yet familiar. Paired with a refreshing Mint Lemonade, made from freshly chopped mint and zesty lemon and lime, this combination feels both decadent and revitalizing.

For main courses, the Beef Kofta shines with its perfectly seasoned beef links cooked alongside hearty potatoes, juicy tomatoes, and onions simmered in a rich red sauce. Accompanied by fluffy white basmati rice, it offers a harmonious blend of taste and texture that truly satisfies. The Shish Taouk features tender marinated chicken skewers, infused with garlic, lemon, and spices, grilled to juicy perfection—a testament to the quality and care taken in cooking each dish.

Olive's Pitaria also prides itself on wholesome sides and lighter options. The Lentil Soup is hearty and spiced just right, a soul-soothing starter on cool days, while the Garlic Yogurt Cucumber salad offers a cool, tangy palate cleanser that pairs wonderfully with grilled meats. The crisp House Salad rounds out the meal with fresh lettuce, diced tomatoes, and cucumbers dressed in a subtle house vinaigrette.

The drinks menu, although concise, complements the menu thoughtfully. Beyond classic sodas like Coca Cola and Sprite, the Hibiscus Heaven intrigues with its floral notes of hibiscus and rose water, offering a delicate sweetness that feels both exotic and refreshing alongside Mediterranean cuisine.

What truly elevates Olive's Pitaria is its warm atmosphere—a blend of comfort and elegance. James C rightly notes the cozy, living-room ambiance that makes dining here feel personal and relaxed. The staff's genuine hospitality enhances the overall experience, making every visit memorable. The restaurant thoughtfully caters to varied dietary needs, with a notable range of gluten-free options ensuring inclusivity.

Customer testimonials resonate with praise for both food and service. From Maryam D's love for the authentic Halal Lebanese dishes to Sydney Baumeister's delight in the consistent quality and attention to detail, the consensus is clear: Olive's Pitaria is a hidden gem that deserves a spot on anyone’s Mediterranean culinary map. Whether you’re a fan of falafel, seeking vibrant salads, or crave the rich spiced meats typical of Middle Eastern fare, Olive’s Pitaria offers a balanced, flavorful journey that feels both familiar and exciting.

In summary, Olive's Pitaria is a harmonious blend of tradition and innovation, delivering Mediterranean dishes crafted with care and passion. Its menu is thoughtful, approachable, and rich in flavor, echoing the heartfelt warmth of its owners and staff. For Cape Girardeau locals and visitors alike, Olive's Pitaria is not just a meal—it’s an experience worth returning to.